Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters: Which One Saves You More Money?

Picking the right water heater is a big decision, it affects your energy costs, how reliably you have hot water, and how much you’ll save over time. So, should you stick with a traditional tank system or make the switch to a high-efficiency tankless model? Both will get the job done, but the real question is: which one will work smarter for your home and your wallet in the long run? 

Let’s break it down together, so you can make the choice that’s right for you.  

Tank Water Heaters: Affordable & Reliable, But Are They Cost-Effective? 

Tank water heaters work by storing hot water in a tank, so it’s ready whenever you need it. That means a steady, reliable supply, but it also means your system uses energy to keep that water warm around the clock, even when you’re not using it. The good news? There are different types of tank water heaters to fit your home’s setup and needs: 

Power Vent Water Heaters - These come with a built-in fan that pushes exhaust outdoors, making them energy-efficient and giving you more flexibility when it comes to installation. 

Chimney Vent Water Heaters - A classic choice that uses your home’s chimney to naturally vent exhaust. It’s a simple, budget-friendly option if your home already has the right venting in place. 

Electric Water Heaters - Fully powered by electricity, these are a great fit for homes without a gas line. They’re usually more affordable upfront, though they can use more energy over time. 

Heat Pump Water Heaters - These smart systems pull heat from the surrounding air to warm your water, making them incredibly energy-efficient. Just keep in mind, they need enough space around them for good airflow. 

Direct Vent Water Heaters - These pull fresh air from outside and vent exhaust directly out of the home, keeping indoor air clean while staying efficient. 

Tankless Water Heaters: Endless Hot Water & Long-Term Savings 

Tankless water heaters heat water only when you need it, no more keeping a full tank warm around the clock. This on-demand design helps cut down on wasted energy, lowers your utility bills over time, and gives you endless hot water without the wait. Plus, these systems are compact and efficient, making them a smart fit for modern homes looking to save space and energy. 

Here are some of the top tankless water heater brands we trust for performance, efficiency, and long-term value: 

Navien Tankless Water Heaters - Built with advanced technology that adjusts water heating based on demand, helping you save on gas and energy without sacrificing comfort. 

Rinnai Tankless Water Heaters - Trusted for durability and long-term savings, Rinnai models are designed for homeowners who want reliable performance and energy efficiency that pays off year after year. 

Cost Savings with Tank Water Heaters VS Tankless Water Heaters 

Cost Factor Tank Water Heater Tankless Water Heater
Lifespan 10-15 Years 20+ Years
Energy Efficiency Less Efficient, Higher Utility Bills Saves Up To 30% On Energy Bills
Annual Operating Cost $400-$600 Per Year $250-$500 Per Year
Installation Complexity Works With Existing Plumbing May Require Gas Line/Electrical Upgrades
Hot Water Supply Limited (runs out when tank is empty) Endless hot water supply
Space Requirement Requires more space for tank storage Compact, wall-mounted design
Long-Term Savings Higher long-term costs due to energy waste and replacements. Higher upfront cost, but energy savings and longevity reduce costs over time. 

Want to Lower Your Costs Even More? Go Lime Can Help! 

At Go Lime, we believe keeping your home comfortable shouldn’t be complicated, or costly. Whether you’re looking for simple maintenance, a full installation, we offer flexible options designed to fit your needs and your budget: 

  • Flexible Subscriptions - Pay monthly and enjoy peace of mind with maintenance and protection included. No surprises, just reliable hot water. 
  • Full Purchase Options - Prefer to own your system outright? We’ll take care of everything, including professional installation. 
  • Affordable Maintenance Services - Keep your water heater running smoothly and efficiently for years to come with routine care from our trusted experts. 

Wondering which option is right for your home? Reach out to us today, we’ll help you find the perfect fit and start saving on your water heating costs. Because comfort should always feel simple.

Upgrading with Go Lime? We’ll Handle the Return of Your Old Water Heater! 

When you upgrade to a new water heater with Go Lime, we make the entire process simple,  from start to finish. No stress, no extra steps, and no heavy lifting on your part. 

  • Old Water Heater Removal - We’ll safely remove your old unit at no extra charge. 
  • Return to Your Provider - If your old water heater was part of a rental, we’ll handle the return process for you, so you don’t have to worry about a thing. 
  • Hassle-Free Upgrade - From installation to cleanup and ongoing maintenance, we’ve got it all covered. You just sit back and enjoy reliable hot water. 

Upgrading your home comfort has never been easier. Shop online with Go Lime and let us handle the hard part, so you can focus on what matters most. 

Ready To Replace Your Old Water Heater?

Get your new hassle-free water heater upgrade installed as early as the same day!

water heater
The Go-To Choice. Trustworthy and Reliable

Our bestselling EnergyStar® Certified water heaters are designed to keep your home comfortable.

Find Your Perfect Fit